Lyme Property Search

Discover Lyme Real Estate

Located on the shores of Chaumont Bay and Lake Ontario, Lyme, NY is a picturesque town known for its charming waterfront communities, peaceful atmosphere, and rich history. From boating and fishing to birdwatching and breathtaking sunsets, Lyme offers a true escape with the convenience of nearby amenities.

Our website features the most accurate and comprehensive search for homes, cottages, land, and foreclosure properties in Lyme—all updated every 15 minutes directly from the official Realtor® database. Whether you're looking for a seasonal cottage on the water or a quiet year-round home, this is the only site you’ll ever need to find real estate in Lyme, NY.

You can save searches, and get daily email alerts of new listings, price changes, sold data, and market reports. Our Interactive Map Search allows you to view properties on a map or refine your search by drawing the boundaries around the area you desire.

Curious about what’s happening in your neighborhood? You can create a custom market report to see what’s active, under contract, and sold in your neighborhood!

Considering selling or refinancing your home? Get an INSTANT property valuation now!

Contact us today to find out how we can be of assistance to you!

Hot Lyme Properties

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ S1713870 MLS

Pack your bags, pick up a few groceries, and start enjoying lake life in this furnished three-bedroom, two-bath home with 75 feet of frontage on the calm waters of Chaumont Bay. The thoughtfully designed, single-level floor plan features an open kitchen, dining area, and living room, with great lake views. For added privacy, the primary suite is located on one side of the home, while the other two bedrooms and second full bath are on the opposite side. Near the end of a short road, the property offers little traffic which encourages wildlife, including possible sightings of bald eagles and fawns. Spend peaceful afternoons with a good book and a cold drink on the waterside deck, then enjoy easy, level access to the bay to cool off. The sale also includes the lot and shed across the road, providing ample space for parking, boat storage, gardens, or other uses. Contact an agent today to schedule a showing before the season ends.

24482 Fire Road 26 N, Lyme

2 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ S1711357 MLS

Here’s your chance to enjoy waterfront living year-round! Situated on 52 feet of Three Mile Bay waterfront, this cozy, well-cared-for home offers beautiful views of the bay and out toward Lake Ontario. Spend your summers on the water with your own dock, or relax on the wonderful waterfront deck and take in the views, sunsets, and fresh lake air. Inside, you’ll find a comfortable open floor plan that makes the home feel warm and welcoming. Upstairs are two bedrooms, including a primary bedroom overlooking the waterfront—imagine waking up to that view every morning! The second bedroom overlooks the huge yard, offering plenty of room to enjoy the outdoors. And there’s more! The property also features two seasonal bunkhouses—perfect for extra guests—a pergola ideal for grilling and outdoor entertaining, plus a 2-car garage with plenty of room for your vehicles, water toys, and gear. And if you hurry, you may even get lucky—the pontoon boat may still be available for sale! Whether you’re looking for a year-round home, waterfront getaway, or a place where family and friends can gather and make memories, this property has so much to offer. Priced to sell—don’t wait! Call, click, or text today for an appointment to see this year round Three Mile Bay waterfront property!

28363 Lotts Grove Road, Lyme

Beautiful 21-acre parcel of tillable land located just minutes from Lake Ontario. Offering open farmland, peaceful surroundings, and excellent potential for agricultural use, investment, or future possibilities. A rare opportunity to own acreage in a desirable location.

Hardscrabble Road, Lyme

2 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ S1711639 MLS

This gorgeous waterfront cottage on Lake Ontario is just waiting to be yours! Completely remodeled over the past few years, this charming getaway features a new metal roof, kitchen appliances, hot water heater, water filtration system, renovated bathroom and bedrooms, plus spacious composite front and side decks—perfect for soaking up those beautiful lake views! Speaking of views! Always mesmerizing, you will get to watch the magnificent ships slowly pass by in the distance! With over 50 feet of waterfront, an amazing seawall, great swimming, kayaking, paddle boarding and even better fishing, this property offers everything you need to enjoy life on the lake! And the best part? It comes furnished! Indoor and outdoor furniture, decor, pots and pans, a grill, and so much more are included, making it easy to move right in and start enjoying your new waterfront retreat. Summer weather is still going strong—there’s time left to make this lake season yours! Don’t miss your chance to own a little piece of heaven on Lake Ontario!

24407 Hayes Bay Road, Lyme

2 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ S1707854 MLS

If you are looking for a hobby farm with a starter home near Lake Ontario, check this place out! This beautifully updated 2-bedroom 1 bath home offers room to roam for you and your animals. All you need to do is show up and fill the barns and chicken coop. Along with 15 acres the property offers a 30x50 barn with generous space. This quiet little piece of heaven sits off Rt 12E a short distance from Lake Ontario and downtown restaurants. This is a dream property for a hobby farmer starting out or someone just looking for a cozy home with some room to stretch and care for their pets. Don't sit on this place.

13081 State Route 12e, Lyme

Wonderful vacant lot on the beautiful Chaumont River! Offering approximately 50 feet of waterfront and 240 feet of depth, this property is just the right size to build your dream camp or seasonal getaway. Enjoy peaceful river views and the opportunity to create your own private retreat. With a blank slate ready for your vision, you can design and develop the space to make it uniquely your own. The parcel cannot be subdivided.

00 Conklin Drive South, Lyme

2 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ S1709650 MLS

Your affordable waterfront getaway awaits on beautiful Chaumont Bay! This adorable and well maintained 2 bedroom, 1 bath ranch style cottage offers approximately 70 feet of waterfront and a fantastic level lot with easy access to the water. Spend your summers swimming, boating, fishing, kayaking, paddleboarding, or simply relaxing and taking in the views. Currently enjoyed as a three season cottage, the property may offer potential for year round use with the addition of a shore well and possible insulation upgrades. Recent improvements include a new metal roof approximately two years ago and newer replacement windows, helping make this an easy, low maintenance retreat. As an added convenience, most furnishings will stay with the property, excluding the sellers' personal items, making it even easier to start enjoying lake life right away. If you have been dreaming of owning a place directly on the water without the upkeep of a larger property, this is a wonderful opportunity to enjoy everything Chaumont Bay and Lake Ontario have to offer. Pack your bags, bring the boat, and start making summer memories at the lake!

26959 Three Mile Point Road, Lyme

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ S1710465 MLS

Cast a line, launch a kayak, or simply take in the views from this pristine, single-owner property on the Chaumont River! The home was built with extreme care and thought, and it shows! A garage and green house at the front of property greet you upon arrival, while a magnificent attached workshop is sure to please even the most discerning artist or craftsperson. The workshop (built in 2008) could be converted to a garage and features in-floor heat - though it is so well insulated, you may never need it! A spacious mudroom with storage connects the workshop to the house and also houses the laundry & utilities. Once inside, you enter to a good sized dining room and sitting room with incredible views of the river. The space is quipped with a gas fireplace and offers direct access to a sun porch & back deck. The kitchen is beautiful with ample counter & storage space and even more terrific views of the Chaumont River. The first floor of home also includes a bedroom with Murphy bed and a full bath. As you head upstairs, you pass through a roomy living room with vaulted ceilings and gorgeous wood beams - it's a real showstopper! The main bedroom with en suite bath overlooks the river below from a cozy window nook of windows, or possible balcony. The third bedrooms also features a custom-made Murphy bed that doubles as a desk when closed. These unique details are found throughout the home and reflect a craftsmanship that won't be found anywhere else. Even the sprawling lawn features charming vignettes and breathtaking landscaping that give the property an one-of-a-kind character. The back deck is truly magical, with gorgeous views and stellar sunsets. Follow a maintained path to the riverfront where you'll find an aluminum dock and huge screened pavilion, perfect for those that love the outdoors but want a more bug-free experience. The Chaumont River itself is great for paddling, fishing, boating, and other aquatic sports. You get the best of both worlds - quiet river life and the action of Lake Ontario just a few minutes downriver by boat! Homes like this are truly rare, so contact an agent today to learn more!

30005 County Route 179, Lyme

Welcome to Beaver Meadow Mews, where your stunning new build lot awaits! Spanning 1.80 acres, this charming property is located in a tranquil, scenic development. You'll enjoy 300 feet of waterfront with a serene, private atmosphere and a protected shoreline. Electric services are included for your convenience. The highly sought-after Chaumont River provides excellent water depth and boating protection, allowing you to embark on picturesque boat rides straight to Lake Ontario in just minutes. Only 20 minutes from the city, this dream lot is an opportunity you won't want to miss. CALL TODAY!

Beaver Meadow, Lyme

4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ S1709109 MLS

Discover this stunning year-round riverfront ranch, perfectly situated on the mouth of the Chaumont River and just a stone's throw away to Lake Ontario. This beautifully maintained four-bedroom, three-bath home rests on a generous lot, blending privacy with accessibility just a short walk from the charming village. Upon entering, you'll be greeted by a spacious open floor plan filled with natural light, seamlessly connecting the living areas. The heart of the home is the gorgeous living room that overlooks the river, complemented by a beautifully appointed kitchen featuring stainless steel appliances and an quaint dining area. Enjoy panoramic views of the Chaumont River, with sliding glass doors that lead to an expansive deck—an ideal spot for entertaining or relaxing with your morning coffee in serene surroundings. The thoughtfully designed layout includes Brazilian hardwood floors throughout, ensuring style and comfort. The primary suite serves as a true retreat, boasting an en-suite bath and picturesque views. Located right at the entrance to Chaumont Bay, this property is renowned for year-round world-class fishing, as well as opportunities for swimming, boating, and wildlife watching. For boating enthusiasts, the river offers excellent protection and deep-water access for larger vessels, making it a prime location for water activities. Plus, it's conveniently situated just minutes from restaurants, shops, marinas, and public beaches, providing an exceptional lifestyle in an unbeatable location. Don’t miss the opportunity to make this stunning riverfront property your forever home!

27747 Water Street, Lyme

Start Your Search