Theresa Property Search

Discover Theresa Real Estate

Nestled in the scenic Thousand Islands region of Jefferson County, Theresa, NY is a charming small town known for its natural beauty, peaceful atmosphere, and outdoor recreation. With nearby lakes, rivers, and state forests, it's a favorite for those who enjoy fishing, boating, hiking, and a slower pace of life.

Our website features the most accurate and up-to-date search for homes, land, condos, and foreclosure properties in Theresa—updated every 15 minutes directly from the official Realtor® database. Whether you're looking for a country home, waterfront lot, or investment opportunity, this is the only site you’ll ever need to find real estate in Theresa, NY.

You can save searches, and get daily email alerts of new listings, price changes, sold data, and market reports. Our Interactive Map Search allows you to view properties on a map or refine your search by drawing the boundaries around the area you desire.

Curious about what’s happening in your neighborhood? You can create a custom market report to see what’s active, under contract, and sold in your neighborhood!

Considering selling or refinancing your home? Get an INSTANT property valuation now!

Contact us today to find out how we can be of assistance to you!

Hot Theresa Properties

6 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ S1715394 MLS

Great investment opportunity in the Village of Theresa! This spacious 4 unit property offers a great combination of income potential, character and flexibility for both investors and owner occupants. Each apartment features generous living space, tall ceilings and charming original details, including beautiful woodwork and hardwood flooring throughout portions of the property. The main level apartment is especially bright and inviting with large windows providing an abundance of natural light. The property does need some cosmetic work and updating, giving the next owner an opportunity to make improvements over time and add their own finishing touches. Outside, you’ll find a good sized, level backyard that is partially fenced, offering additional outdoor space for tenants to enjoy. Three of the four units are currently rented, generating $2,150 per month in rental income, while the vacant unit provides an excellent opportunity for an owner occupant or the ability to secure an additional tenant and increase overall income. Water and sewer are included in the rent. Additional features include an on demand water heater and some updated flooring. Whether you are looking to expand an existing rental portfolio, purchase your first investment property or live in one unit while the others help offset your mortgage, this 4 unit property offers plenty of possibilities in the heart of Theresa.

204 Commercial Street, Theresa

1 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ S1714899 MLS

Calling all bachelors, bachelorettes, empty nesters, and anyone who's ever wanted a garage that doubles as a hangout, this one was made for you. Heated and insulated, this garage isn't just for parking, pull in your vehicles or your project car, then unwind at your own built-in bar with a convenient half bath just steps away, so you never have to run inside mid-project or mid-game. Above the garage, you'll find a comfortable one bedroom, one bath living quarters, giving you the option to live right where you work and play. Upstairs, the updated kitchen means the hard work is already done for you. In-floor heat has been started in this space, ready for you to finish it out and add that extra layer of comfort for the winter months. Need even more room to work? A separate heated workshop with electric gives you dedicated space for tools, projects, or a home business, completely apart from the garage and living area. And when it comes to storage, you're covered — three separate sheds mean lawn equipment, seasonal gear, recreational toys, and extra tools all have a home of their own, keeping your main spaces clutter-free. There's also room to grow here. The property offers space to expand the existing structure or potentially build a second home on the lot, so whether you're planning for down the road or want to add value now, the option is on the table. Location works in your favor too. You're about 20 minutes from Watertown for shopping, dining, and everyday errands, and about 20 minutes from Fort Drum, making this a smart, convenient option for anyone who wants small-town quiet without sacrificing an easy commute. This property is built for someone who wants more than a house, someone who wants a space to tinker, entertain, store their gear, and unwind on their own terms. Whether you're setting up your first place, downsizing to something more manageable, or just want a low-maintenance property with serious garage and workshop space, this one is worth seeing in person!

25920 Dano Road, Theresa

1 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ S1713084 MLS

Nearly 30 acres of privacy and possibility along the Indian River in the Town of Theresa! This beautiful parcel offers a mix of mature hardwoods and cleared, open land, with almost 500 feet of water frontage on the Indian River, part of the renowned Indian River Lakes system, a chain of interconnected waters known for smallmouth bass, walleye, and pike fishing. Wildlife is abundant here, including deer, and the property sits all framed by gorgeous water views. With cleared land up front near the road and additional open ground down by the water, there's flexibility to build your dream home in either setting, whether you prefer road frontage convenience or a waterfront build. A rustic hunting cabin already on site features electric, a composting toilet, an outdoor shower, and its own well; just needs some TLC to be back up and running! Enjoy fishing and canoeing right off your own shoreline. Conveniently located close to Watertown and Fort Drum, with countless other North Country lakes a short drive away. Whether you're picturing a hunting camp, a family retreat, or your own slice of Northern New York wilderness, this property brings acreage, water, wildlife, and location together in one rare offering. Schedule your showing today!

36720 County Route 46, Theresa

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ S1703496 MLS

Discover the charm & privacy of country living in this 1-owner turnkey contemporary home. This property offers a peaceful setting w/plenty of space to enjoy the outdoors, making it a great place to call HOME!! This impeccably maintained home features 3 bedrooms, all on the same floor & all w/walk-in closets, 2 baths, including the primary suite, an open floor plan, kitchen w/breakfast bar & living room, great space for entertaining, a large formal dining room, a bonus room (or could be a 4th bedroom), and upstairs there is a family room and spacious attic that could be finished off for additional living space. This home has in-floor heat throughout, an attached garage, 3 storage sheds, and a good-sized composite deck overlooking the beautiful backyard. This home sits on a little over 7 acres, so you have lots of space, privacy & the best of rural living, yet it's just a short drive to Fort Drum & local conveniences. If you are looking for a move-in-ready home w/room to roam, you will definitely want to look at this. Don't delay, call or text today to schedule your private showing. **FAST CLOSING POSSIBLE**

28303 Joyner Road, Theresa

2 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ S1702437 MLS

Incredible opportunity in the heart of the Indian River Lakes region! This quiet corner-lot property sits on a dead-end road just minutes from Lake of the Woods, with a state boat/beach launch right on Cottage Hill Road for easy water access. You're also close to Millsite Lake, Grass Lake, and Muskellunge Lake — a paradise for anglers and boaters, with northern pike, bass, walleye, trout, salmon, and panfish throughout the chain. Well, septic, and electric are already on site, so tear down the existing home and build your dream getaway, or add a garage to store your boat through the winter. Owner financing available. Property being sold as-is.

32420 Carpenter Road, Theresa

3 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ S1700459 MLS

Come check out this amazing 16 acre lakefront lot on stunning spring fed Red Lake! This incredible off grid getaway boasts 250' of pristine lakefront with sand! Total privacy and wooded bliss will be yours and you will get to enjoy a lake with very few neighbors and much of it is conservatory and state owned! You will also find yourself close to tons of state land for hunting etc.! Red Lake is amazing swimming, fishing and yes even boating! Tons of wildlife like deer, bear and so much more!! This lot has no electric available and it will be off grid only, also on seasonal private drive. This is truly spectacular private oasis like no other! Call today!!

00 Sheley Road Unit 85, Theresa

2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ S1700073 MLS

Here is your rare one of a kind Off Grid 4 season getaway!!! Or your dream home if privacy and a rare country location is your goal! Come tour this incredible 2 bedroom/2 bath Red Lake Home with over 21 acres of land and over 300' of pristine sand beach frontage! Breathtaking views or Red Lake which is mostly state owned so very limited neighbors!! Solar runs this home with generator hookup for backup energy and current owner as resided here year-round since it was built in 2001. Walk into your attached 2 car garage, Cpzy kitchen, nice living/dining area with all custom Cherry built in's, main bedroom and bath on 1st floor plus a sauna! Walkout basement features a 2nd bedroom, full bath plus den/game room area with beautiful bar area all custom! The land is awesome and features mature orchards! Take your side by side down to the beach where you will find the crystal-clear waters of Red Lake! You are only 1 mile from the town plowed road, close to ATV areas, and all the Indian River Lakes have to offer! Fabulous fishing, wildlife galore, deer, bear you name it!! This is truly a once in a lifetime property!!! Call today!

42281 Honey Hill Road, Theresa

2 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ S1693389 MLS

Enjoy easy lake living in this charming 2-bedroom, 1-bath cottage located on the same street as beautiful Muskellunge Lake. This move-in-ready getaway features an open floor plan with soaring cathedral ceilings, creating a bright and spacious atmosphere. The property includes deeded right-of-way access to the lake, along with place to launch your boat—perfect for fishing, boating, and enjoying everything the lake has to offer.

43668 Muskelunge Lake Camp Road, Theresa

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ S1692102 MLS

Now offering Rent to Own! Escape to the privacy and tranquility of country living with this beautifully updated 3 bed, 2 bath home situated on 6.49 secluded acres surrounded by mature trees. Located at the end of a dead end road and tucked well away from the hustle and bustle, this property offers exceptional privacy while still providing convenient access to Fort Drum, local amenities, and the many lakes, rivers, and outdoor recreation the North Country is known for. Inside, you'll find fresh paint throughout and newer flooring that give the home a clean, updated feel. The bright, open concept layout creates a welcoming atmosphere ideal for both everyday living and entertaining. The spacious kitchen is filled with natural light and offers plenty of room for cooking and gathering, while the adjoining dining area provides the perfect setting for family meals, holiday celebrations, and hosting guests. The inviting living room features a cozy wood burning fireplace, creating a warm and comfortable gathering space during cooler months. The primary bedroom offers its own cozy retreat with an electric fireplace, adding warmth and ambiance for relaxing evenings at home. The massive closet has great built-ins for your entire wardrobe. You'll never have to switch out your winter clothes for your summer clothes again! Step outside to the expansive deck, ideal for entertaining guests, hosting summer barbecues, or simply relaxing while taking in the surrounding natural beauty. A charming gazebo nestled among the trees provides an additional outdoor retreat, perfect for enjoying your morning coffee, unwinding with a good book, or gathering with friends and family while surrounded by nature. The fenced side yard provides a great space for pets, gardening, or outdoor activities, while the storage sheds offer additional room for tools and equipment. Whether you're looking for a year round residence or a peaceful retreat close to Fort Drum and the area's many lakes, this property offers the privacy, space, and charm you've been searching for. Come experience the serenity of country living while remaining just a short drive from everything the North Country has to offer.

110 Ralston Street, Theresa

6 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ S1684204 MLS

GREAT PRICE FOR A RARE FIND!! The Snell-Gillett House, listed on the National Register of Historic Places, is a grandly spacious, circa 1880 Queen Anne Victorian. It features nearly 10’ ceilings, original carved moulding, hardwood floors, stained glass and more! The double front carved doors with inlaid stained glass panels open into a formal entry hall with an antique brass chandelier, an ornately carved staircase, two magnificent 5-ft-wide hardwood pocket doors, ornate brass doorknobs and two fireplaces – one wood-burning and one propane. NEW Metal roof (2024), Propane fireplace (2024), Kitchen (2026), and Eighteen (18) double-paned windows (2025-6), have all been installed for your comfort and convenience. With six (6) bedrooms, three (3) baths and space galore, the opportunities to make it your dream home are practically endless! If you’re looking for an historic home with original details, or with the potential to convert part of the space to an in-law suite, office, or even an income-producing Air BnB, this house offers a myriad of opportunities! The original carriage house was converted to a 2 car garage and a separate office/workshop with electricity, plumbing, and baseboard heat, and a loft you can finish as you choose. Located in the Village of Theresa with Theresa electric utilities, the property is only 1 ½ blocks to Theresa Primary School or the Indian River, and just minutes to Fort Drum, the St. Lawrence River, the 1000 Islands, 12 lakes, and Watertown. Schedule a private showing today!!

213 Mill Street, Theresa

Start Your Search